Clinical Psychology Bite-Size
Clinical Psychology Bite-Size aims to provide short and readable summaries of mental health research, theory and implications for practice. When it started in 2008 the initial aim was to provide articles which would encourage staff to develop a more questioning approach to their practice and to enhance more social and psychological understandings within the workforce. Originally all articles were written by the Trust’s Adult Mental Health Clinical Psychology department. Since that time both the distribution and range of authors has increased but the philosophy remains the same. Each Bite-Size takes a critical perspective to concepts and theories of mental distress, with a particular emphasis on highlighting social and psychological factors as well as emphasising the past and current context. Mental health services continue to be dominated by a biogenetic and medical model, in contrast, bite-size aims to discuss alternative models and understanding of human suffering and distress. It looks to give a rigorous analysis of the ways in which services currently try to help including psychological and pharmacological approaches. Further, it may look at the context and systems surrounding mental health services. Bite-Size also tries to understand and give weight to the experiential and personal meanings of service users’ distress. The perspectives within Clinical Psychology Bite-Size are those of the named authors, whose details are provided if the reader wishes to contact them. For general enquiries about Clinical Psychology Bite-Size please contact one of the Editors, either Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org) or Philip Houghton (email@example.com). If you would like to receive the latest editions Clinical Psychology Bite-Size direct to your e-mail address please contact Jenny Poole (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Steven Coles (Clinical Psychologist) and Philip Houghton (Clinical Psychologist).Co-Editors of Clinical Psychology Bite-Size.
Trauma and Psychosis: What Has Happened to You?
Issue 37 – December 2013Authors: Steven Coles (email@example.com)
- There is a growing body of research recognising that a range of traumatic circumstances are a cause of experiences labelled as psychosis or schizophrenia.
The Complexity of Responsibility
Issue 36 – September 2013Authors: Philip Houghton (firstname.lastname@example.org) and Steven Coles (email@example.com)
- People often do not know why they act the way they do
- A judgement of responsibility can limit how we understand a situation and its complexity
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 5
Issue 35 – May 2013Authors: Aisling Mannion (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- There are increasing concerns that understandable reactions to traumatic situations are being pathologised
- Many studies highlight a financial conflict of interest between those involved in forming diagnostic categories and the pharmaceutical industry
Critique of the Evidence Base for Mental Health Treatments
Issue 34 – February 2013Authors: Aisling Mannion (email@example.com)
- Randomised Control Trials (RCTs) are considered the ‘gold standard’ for research, and clinical guidelines are based on the findings of these studies. However, RCTs have a number of disadvantages
- A vast literature exists highlighting the importance of non-specific factors, such as a good therapeutic relationship, over the choice of treatment modality
Collaborative Decision Making
Issue 33 – December 2012Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Collaborative decision making requires forming a shared understanding of an issue
- Different professionals and service users can have assumptions, values and goals that are in conflict with each other
- Legal, organisational and professional forms of power can inhibit equality in decision making
Is insight enough?
Issue 32 – October 2012Author: Aisling Mannion (email@example.com)
- The aim of most therapies is to increase insight
- Insight focuses on the individual, ignoring important external factors. The concept of outsight (looking outwards to the wider world) is a useful alternative
- Insight as a concept may vary across cultures. We need to bear in mind cultural attributions of mental illness when defining insight
- Psychotherapy and psychiatric practice are cultural practices, which contain Western assumptions and values
The role of language in mental health
Issue 31 – July 2012Author: Victoria O’Key (c/o firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Language does not simply reflect the way events are, but shapes the way we see and experience them.
- The language we use serves particular functions (e.g. blaming, justifying).
- The terminology used to make sense of emotional distress is very powerful, and greatly influences how service users see themselves.
- Some ways of talking about distress are more stigmatising than others. For instance, labelling someone’s personality as ‘disordered’ is likely to be shaming.
Compassionate Mind Training
Issue 30 – May 2012Author: Phil Houghton (email@example.com)
- Compassionate Mind Training is a therapeutic approach designed to enhance compassion
- Compassion is seen as the cornerstone for developing happiness and a meaningful life, but we need to be more modest with regards to its impact.
An Alternative to Challenging Unusual Beliefs
Issue 29 – November 2011Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Beliefs deemed unusual hold some form of meaning and function for people
- We all hold beliefs that cannot be proven or that parts of society might disagree with
- Challenging a person’s beliefs carries the risk of leaving a someone feeling criticised, shamed and could lead to disengagement from services
Ethics in Clinical Practice: What’s the right thing to do?
Issue 28 – July 2011Author: Phil Houghton (email@example.com)
- Within clinical practice we are often faced with the question “what’s the right thing to do?”
- Whilst we can not guarantee making the “right” decision, ethical frameworks exist which can help us make decisions in the right way
Diagnosis of Personality Disorder
Issue 27 – April 2011Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Research has shown that the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder is stigmatising
- The diagnosis can be seen as a moral judgement rather than a scientific or medical concept
- People given this label have often experienced abuse, trauma and disordered environments
Employment and Mental Health
Issue 26 – January 2011Author: Sarah Keenan (email@example.com)
- Employment influences community well-being and individual levels of distress.
- Fair wages and meaningful work are as important as whether someone is employed or not.
- Poor or financially inadequate employment has similar negative psychological effects to unemployment.
- Adequate employment is important as it reduces poverty and provides a daily structure and collective identity.
Growing up in care: implications for adult mental health
Issue 25 – November 2010Author: Miranda Roberts (c/o firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Looked after children have commonly experienced abuse or neglect in their birth families and have lacked safe and responsive relationships with caregivers
- Even after leaving their birth families and entering care, children do not necessarily receive care which meets their needs and may continue to experience rejection and instability
- These experiences are likely to have an ongoing impact on people who have grown up in the care system and are likely to contribute to mental health problems in adulthood.
Psychosis in Early Motherhood
Issue 24 – September 2010Author: Amanda Campbell (c/o email@example.com)
- Women are particularly at risk of mental health problems in the time after childbirth
- Psychosis in this time is predominantly understood as caused by biological and hormonal changes but could also be understood as driven by the significant life changes and experiences that occur prior to, during and after childbirth
- Childbirth is a time of many social expectations and pressures, with the expectation of being a time of fulfilment, joy and development of the bond between mother and child.
- Mental health problems do not fit the social ideal of motherhood as a time of fulfilment
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
Issue 23 – July 2010Author: Phil Houghton (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- The Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) model argues that much suffering is caused by trying to avoid or control painful experiences.
- ACT focuses on helping people to accept their painful experiences, choose valued directions in life and take action towards those values.
- A criticism of the ACT model is that it pays little attention to people’s social context and the inequality that means some people experience more aversive and painful events than others, and also have less resources to address these difficulties.
Contextualising Distress I: Background and Power-mapping
Issue 20 – January 2010Author: Steven Coles (email@example.com)
- There is evidence for all forms of distress being shaped by a person’s social world and life experiences
- The limited attention to the context of people’s distress has led to power being concealed
- Rather than understanding power as residing within a person, power can be seen as acting between and through people.
Understanding and Working with Self-Harm
Issue 19 – November 2009Author: Gareth Foote (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Self-harm is a way of coping with difficult feelings and situations and is therefore considered a survival strategy
- People who use self-harm often report being stigmatised and labelled in unhelpful ways by health services. Paradoxically this maintains self-harm as it reinforces their negative view of themselves and the belief that they are unworthy of the support of others, or that others cannot or will not help them, and ultimately will reject them
Adult Attachment and Mental Health
Issue 18 – September 2009Author: Emma Bodfield (c/o email@example.com)
- Attachment Theory concerns the way we relate to others. It includes a person’s view of themselves as deserving of support and whether others are able to meet their needs.
- Insecure attachment is linked to mental health problems. Such insecurity can be developed through childhood trauma, adversity and neglect.
- The coercive aspects of services may limit their ability to provide safe, trusting relationships to service users and impact on our ability to meet their attachment needs.
Making Sense of Paranoia
Issue 17 – August 2009
Authors: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org) and John Cromby (email@example.com)
- Suspicious and paranoid feelings and beliefs are on a continuum with ‘normal’ experiences.
- Victimisation, discrimination and lack of power in the world appear to be causes of paranoia.
- Unusual beliefs are likely to reflect important themes or thwarted goals in a person’s life.
- Difficult social experiences can lead to shameful, angry or fearful feelings. Mixtures of these feelings can shape perceptions of the world and give rise to paranoid beliefs.
Issue 16 – July 2009Author: Bob Diamond (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- User involvement at all levels of mental health services significantly contributes towards a more informed and personally meaningful understanding of distress.
- User involvement improves the effectiveness of care and support provided by Mental Health services by promoting a shared dialogue between workers and people who use services.
- There is a huge variation nationally of user involvement within Mental Health services, the debate continues as to whether real influences on services can be achieved through user involvement being situated within or outside of services.
Issue 15 – June 2009Author: Sarah Keenan (email@example.com)
- Many people feel they have little influence over making decisions about their psychiatric medication.
- It is important for people who take, or are thinking about taking psychiatric medication to feel supported in asking questions about medication, finding out about alternative ways of coping with distress and accessing relevant and understandable information. Medication groups are one way of facilitating this.
Social Ranking Model of Distress
Issue 14 – May 2009Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Social ranking theory emphasises the importance of social relationships to our well-being
- People who are unable to escape difficult circumstances (e.g. domestic violence, difficult neighbourhoods etc) are likely to be distressed (including feeling ‘depressed’)
- Difficulties in a person’s early environment can also lead to a person having low self-worth
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Psychosis
Issue 13 – April 2009Author: Phil Houghton (email@example.com)
- We need to adopt a more modest and questioning view of CBT for psychosis, as whilst it can be a helpful approach the evidence base is not as strong as is sometimes suggested
Issue 12 – March 2009Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- There are a number of ways to make sense of the experience of hearing voices
- For some people and cultures hearing voices is viewed as a gift
- The experience of voice hearing is shaped by a person’s social world and personal history
Sexuality and mental health
Issue 11 – February 2009Author: Sarah Fairbank (email@example.com)
- Historically sexuality and mental health has been viewed negatively, and service users are often pathologised as either asexual or deviant.
- Sexuality is not routinely addressed with service users, despite the focus on holistic care and research suggesting that sexuality is an important part of self.
Families and Psychosis
Issue 10 – January 2009Author: Sarah Keenan (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- There have been different understandings relating to the causes of psychosis, and these have been echoed in therapeutic approaches to working with families.
- Families are one amongst many complex factors that influence well-being (positively and negatively). Therefore we need to consider family influences when thinking about the cause and maintenance of distress.
- A family’s social context and access to material and social resources is likely to influence the distress of each family member.
Values Based Practice
Issue 9 – December 2008Author: Phil Houghton (email@example.com)
- Values Based Practice (VBP) stresses that clinical decisions are not just about “evidence”, but are influenced by the differing values people have
- The strengths of VBP are that it argues that the service user perspective should be the start of any clinical discussion and highlights the weaknesses of Evidence based Practice
- The major weakness of VBP is that it fails to acknowledge that the people involved in any decision may have vastly different amounts of power to influence the outcome
Issue 08 – November 2008 Author: Bob Diamond (Robert.firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Community psychology primarily emphasises social influences on well-being and distress
- It advocates values such as respect, equality and justice
- It promotes preventative work that addresses racism, sexism and all forms of discrimination
Childhood Trauma and ‘Psychosis’
Issue 07 – October 2008Author: Sarah Fairbank and Steven Coles (email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Research suggests that child abuse can lead to ‘psychotic’ experiences such as ‘hallucinations’ and ‘delusions’ later in life
- This research has caused debate and controversy particularly for biological and genetically oriented psychiatric practitioners
- The focus on childhood trauma should not mean that other difficulties such as poverty and racism are ignored when considering psychological distress
Difficulties with Diagnosis
Issue 06 – September 2008
- There appears to be a continuum between what is deemed ‘psychotic’ and so-called normality, rather than distinct diagnostic categories.
- Unlike medical diagnosis in physical health, psychiatric diagnosis lacks clear physical markers (signs) and is reliant on what clients say and do (symptoms).
- Psychiatric diagnosis does not appear to reflect real or meaningful categories.
- Diagnosis of “schizophrenia” is a poor predictor of outcome (symptomatically and socially) and does not indicate response to specific psychiatric medications.
Issue 05 – August 2008
Author: Christine Collinson (email@example.com)Key points
- The idea that delusions can be separated from non-delusional beliefs and are a sign of an underlying illness is controversial, as is the notion that they are a problem to be removed.
- Delusional or unusual beliefs may hold an important function and have meaning.
- What we consider to be unusual beliefs reflect life concerns and goals.
Religious beliefs and working with psychosis
Issue 04 – July 2008
Author: Sarah Keenan (firstname.lastname@example.org)Key points
- Professional training and practice guidelines are often vague about how to work with religious beliefs.
- Religious beliefs influence coping strategies and recovery, therefore it is important to feel comfortable to sensitively ask clients about them.
Being TherapeuticIssue 3 – June 2008 Author: Bob Diamond (email@example.com)
- Therapy and therapeutic relationships are shown to be helpful for service users approximately 50-60% of the time, although some sources suggest the figure is lower.
- Many studies over a number of years looking at outcome in therapy have shown there are few differences between particular therapeutic models.
- Common factors in therapy such as, trust, warmth, understanding and acceptance may be the most effective factors in therapy.
Discrimination, Ethnicity and Psychosis
Issue 02 – May 2008
Author: Steven Coles (firstname.lastname@example.org)
- Evidence points to environmental factors rather than genetic / biological factors as the reason for the increased rate of psychosis in some ethnic minority groups. Social factors in particular have been put forward as likely.
- Encountering discrimination seems to be related to people experiencing ‘delusional ideation’ at a later time.
- Individual discrimination can be subtle as well as blatant. Subtle forms can be as psychologically damaging as more obvious forms.
Issue 01 – April 2008
Author: Philip Houghton (email@example.com)
- The “illness” model of ‘psychosis’ is just one amongst many ways of understanding ‘psychosis’
- Social, economic, cultural, historical and psychological factors all influence the development and maintenance of psychotic experiences